I wrote a pinned post about going too far with the negative, with venting, etc. recently. And it sure appears that my contention that some people are negative people....just are that way-has been soundly proven. Some of them became innovative with their insults to the Ducks; discussing the obvious negative is fine, but going over-the-top several times?

Notice all the traffic we had after a loss? Note how much it declined after a win? There are a great many people who posted after losses, but when we win and do many good things--do they post then?

No.

We have a number of great posters who give opinions BOTH positive and negative, and some of them are new. I hope all you will continue to do that, and as for those who we only hear from when it is negative?

If We Lose to Ohio State....I'm Sure We'll Hear From You Again! (Right?)

Oh my....

Some people just need tea and sympathy.

And yes they will be back next time we lose.

Edited 9 hours ago9 hr by Solar

So what if people vent, and are more active following a loss? It’s called emotion and far more emotions (blowing off steam) happen following losses.

You can pick apart a loss far easier than a win.

More fun to win but there will be fewer interactions. Just normal behavior.

I don't think it is just losing, but how and why they are losing.

This season's OC promotion, the offensive style with Cristobal, the Brady Hoke disaster will bring out a lot of posts and rightly so.

But I totally agree that when things turn around (and they always do) that we should see the same peeps giving street cred for the comeback. Or else why are you here?

It has been a tough year and the toughest game is next up. So even if the Ducks lose, if they can show they are improving the x's and o's, fighting hard, knowing their assignments, and showing pride and mojo in what they do, there should be some good posts supporting the cause.

But on the other hand, if they are lost and totally unprepared like the Ok St game, then I can't expect too much from my fellow fishduck homies. Some of it is on them.

7 hours ago, oregon123 said:

I don't think it is just losing, but how and why they are losing.

Even discussing the negative on that is fine. This is a very astute group of people, but I have a hard time conveying the difference between discussing negative, versus going over-the-top negative and venting. We have a rule against venting No. 31, and suggest people read No. 31a, also, 31b especially, and 31d.

My concern is that those who have great observations that are negative will not post, as they don't understand that I want the negative posts, but not the innovative insults and the venting.

We've been through this before with the final year of Cristobal, and the year of losing to the Huskies twice....was quite a meltdown for some. Again negative is fine, as that is what we do in a forum. And I have certainly not only participated in posting negative, but made jokes in the process.

You are a great example of posting both ways, and I appreciate that. It gives you much more credibility with your negative posts when you post positive along with them. And I understand that some years, like this one, we are going to have a ton more negative posts. It is the way it is, and I've tolerated a TON more than I prefer, but since they did not break the rules....I let them all stay.

It was observation on my part about human nature, as being a moderator for thousands of posts--I've learned a ton about our tendencies over the years.

9 hours ago, Cigarstar said:

So what if people vent, and are more active following a loss? It’s called emotion and far more emotions (blowing off steam) happen following losses.

You can pick apart a loss far easier than a win.

More fun to win but there will be fewer interactions. Just normal behavior.

See the post above, (No. 5) as you are new here and have not been through what the rest of us have with venting. And we have a rule against it because it has been such a problem in the past.

What we see is normal behavior....it is human nature, and it is interesting to watch it play out, hence my observation.