Going back to the Big 8, the best teams - Nebraska, Oklahoma, Missouri, and Colorado all are mediocre or terrible in their new conferences.

They only looked good back then due to who they were playing.

In today's Big 12, it is still mostly the same. I'll bet that even Michigan could beat most of their top teams today.

If I am wrong (and I could be), lets see how they look vs Big 10 or SEC teams in the playoffs.

There is still too much emphasis out on the big 12 by the committee.

I honestly believe this Oregon team right now would beat the Utes. The personnel difference is just too big.

Would Utah even stand a chance against Georgia?

I am not saying you two are wrong, but OBD lost to OK State, which lost last night to Texas Tech.

This sort of comparison is somewhat arbitrary, but what method would be more equitable?

I am trying to see this from the perspective of BYU et al.

3 minutes ago, Triphibius said:

I am not saying you two are wrong, but OBD lost to OK State, which lost last night to Texas Tech.

This sort of comparison is somewhat arbitrary, but what method would be more equitable?

I am trying to see this from the perspective of BYU et al.

We did lose to Ok State at the start of the season and I'm not saying the Ducks deserve to be the in playoff at this point, we didn't take care of business and that's on this team.

But has Utah played the same tier of athletes that are in the big ten? Would they beat Ohio State? Would they be competitive with Georgia as no.1 and no.2 should be theoretically competitive with each other.

Just feels like the committee is treating the big 12 like it still had Texas and Oklahoma, of which how would they stack up in the Big 12 right now? Neither are great but they are both playing against better rosters than the Big 12.

If Oregon makes it into the playoff and has to square off against Utah... I'm betting on the Ducks (this version anyways).

If this were the BCS and it was Georgia v Utah in the national championship game I'm betting on Georgia big time.

There is just much bigger jump between the power two to the ACC and Big 12 and the committee isn't recognizing that... Yet.

This also isn't to say I don't think Utah deserves a playoff spot. They do... But are they really the no. 2 team on the country?