14 hours ago14 hr No. After winning three consecutive national championships, on the surface, it appears the B1G is having an off year. In 2023, Michigan finally put it all together with a stifling defense and a veteran QB. Ohio St. rode strong senior leadership with young generational talent to win it all in 2024. And Indiana caught lightning in a bottle last season, For 2026, Top 25 voters and the playoff committee have been looking for a reason to drop both UCLA and Indiana and now they've been given that opportunity after they both lost earlier today.Come tomorrow afternoon and Tuesday evening, the B1G is poised to be without a team in the Top 10 for the first time since (possibly) Week 2 of the 2012 season (feel free to check my homework). The question will be how steep UCLA's punishment for losing a road game is coupled with losing another starting quarterback. I could see Indiana falling below Oregon (which is wild having one more loss than the defending champions), but jumping a UCLA team that beat us and still has two less losses is a bridge too far. I estimate the B1G will occupy spots 11-14 consistently in the polls and CFP rankings.So the question I pose is, "is the B1G really struggling more this year compared to the other conferences?" Most of the teams have changed dramatically throughout the season. I have us as 4-10 in head to head matchups against the Power 4 (and Notre Dame) from earlier in the season with only one win against a Power 4 team with a winning record (Michigan over Oklahoma).I think the first and foremost contributing factor has been injured and wildly inconsistent quarterbacks for the B1G. One thing every other Top 10 team has in common is that they all still have their starting QBs or changed voluntarily for improvement. Are there other factors?
14 hours ago14 hr Moderator No. 11 minutes ago, mikethehiker said:I think the first and foremost contributing factor has been injured and wildly inconsistent quarterbacks for the B1G.Off the top of my head, B1G teams with backup QBs due to injury:OregonUCLAIndianaOhio StateMichigan StateSo, yeah.
14 hours ago14 hr Moderator No. But there is a question of WHY the B1G has lost so many starting QBs.Is the B1G more aggressive on defense?I DO think there are a lot of no-calls that would have definitely been called in the OG P12. B1G refs don’t seem to believe in defensive pass interference.Honestly, I haven’t watched a single other conference’s game, so I have no idea how other conferences call games. The OG P12 is my only frame of reference.But it does seem like it might be more than an unfortunate coincidence.
8 hours ago8 hr Moderator No. 5 hours ago, Jon Joseph said:Does the Sun rise in the East? 🙃Is a bear Catholic? Does the Pope 💩 in the woods?
5 hours ago5 hr Moderator No. No doubt the B1G zebras allow both DBs and OLs to be a bit more 'handsy'. But would any of us want to go back to old PAC12 laundry-fest where a DB hand anywhere on a WR resulted in 15 and a 1st. Not only did it result in occasionally being banished to the car to watch the game on a cellphone ("Honey, stop screaming at the TV!"), but it hurt PAC teams in bowl and playoff games when facing teams and refs that didn't play by tiky-tac rules. You don't have to allow a grab that pulls one of those breakaway jersey liners 5 yards behind the DB, but let the boys play.IMHO most of the B1G QBs lost this year have been to either freak events, normal wear and tear injuries or the occasional egregious head shot and not related to officiating
4 hours ago4 hr No. Let me throw this out there... If Lanning nailed the initial OC hiring (let's just say he hire Johnson out the gate for the sake of argument).... Oregon is 11-0 (yes the Ducks looked bad on defense against ok state in this scenario but the offense actually did things to win). Ducks sitting at no. 1 in conference and no. 1 in the poll. And I'm factoring in Moore going down against USC and us playing Raiola. Our three losses were seriously that close that a change in OC probably makes all the difference. And when it comes to losses... It's not just how many you lose but how you lose and WHEN you lose. Also being a blue blood tends to help out in that scenario too. Which is why even if Ohio State and Michigan are a bit down this year don't take those wins for granted... They count a bit more because they are against blue blood programs.
3 hours ago3 hr Moderator No. 10 hours ago, Dr Hilarius said:But there is a question of WHY the B1G has lost so many starting QBs.Is the B1G more aggressive on defense?I DO think there are a lot of no-calls that would have definitely been called in the OG P12.B1G refs don’t seem to believe in defensive pass interference.Honestly, I haven’t watched a single other conference’s game, so I have no idea how other conferences call games. The OG P12 is my only frame of reference.But it does seem like it might be more than an unfortunate coincidence.Here's an interesting non-stat from yesterday. The BYU-at-Kansas game went into triple OT. Not a single penalty was called.Big Ten teams with QBs who missed games with injury: Oregon, Ohio State, Washington, UCLA, Iowa, Wisconsin, Rutgers, Maryland, Michigan State, Indiana, and Northwestern.
3 hours ago3 hr No. How about we wait til AFTER the CFP to pronounce a down year for the B1G?We have heard the diatribe too long that the good teams of the SEC eat themselves. Could it be that the every bit as good B1G teams are eating themselves in the regular season? Let’s see how deep into the playoffs we get before crowning someone else.Just sayin. Go Ducks!
2 hours ago2 hr No. I think it's simply the old Pac-12 effect since 4 of the strongest teams from that old mess joined B1G - and all 4 are playing big roles in messing up the PO chances for the conference!
2 hours ago2 hr Moderator No. 32 minutes ago, 1Ducker1 said:I think that defenses are getting better throughout college football.Good call. The clock changes have shortened the games and taken away the HUNH style of play on offense.
2 hours ago2 hr No. Miami was the last team in last year at 10-2 and played in the championship game. A 3 loss team could do the same this year. Next year 4 loss teams might win a few playoff games. The playoffs are getting much more forgiving for teams that hit a rough patch, but figure it out and peak at the right time
2 hours ago2 hr Moderator No. 44 minutes ago, PittDuck said:How about we wait til AFTER the CFP to pronounce a down year for the B1G?We have heard the diatribe too long that the good teams of the SEC eat themselves. Could it be that the every bit as good B1G teams are eating themselves in the regular season?Let’s see how deep into the playoffs we get before crowning someone else.Just sayin.Go Ducks!Good post. But after the UCLA and Indiana OT losses and the B12 teams holding serve, the Big Ten could be a one-bid PO conference.Is there a B1G team that can and will win four consecutive road games?
1 hour ago1 hr No. "Big Ten could be a one-bid PO conference"This not fantasy, it is a legit comment. The AP and Coaches ranking today really diminishes the Big Ten. The low rankings mean the so-called "good wins" are diminished. If the CFP ranking Tuesday is similar it will be an SEC bias fest for the CFP. No conference other than the SEC gets the benefit of the doubt in terms of parity. In an 11+1 selection I'm not sure if any team other than the B1G Champion gets in. And, whomever it is better hope for No. 8 or above.
1 hour ago1 hr Moderator No. How low can you go? 🤬🤬🤬https://www.espn.com/college-football/story/_/id/50563638/no-big-ten-football-teams-ap-top-5-first-21For the first time since 2021, no Big Ten team is ranked in the top 5.
6 minutes ago6 min No. 3 hours ago, PittDuck said:We have heard the diatribe too long that the good teams of the SEC eat themselves. Could it be that the every bit as good B1G teams are eating themselves in the regular season?Food teams ate themselves in the ole Pac-12. We were just so far out west that no one thought those teams were actually good. The era of super teams is coming to an end. Saban's Bama did a whole lot of heavy lifting for the SEC. Ohio State and Michigan have done a whole lot of heavy lifting for the Big Ten. Again.... Get a good OC out the gate and the Ducks are in a different place. I also feel the committee is over valuing the big 12 but I guess we'll find out how true that is in the near future. Kinda hoping we get Utah in round two and get to dismantle them.
Create an account or sign in to comment